J. R. Kerr,(1) V. S. Cunniffe,(1) P. Kelleher,(2) R. M. Bernstein,(3) and I. N. Bruce(3)
(1)Department of Microbiology, Royal Brompton Hospital, and (2)Department of Immunology, Wright-Fleming Institute, Imperial College London, London, and (3)Rheumatism Research Centre, Central Manchester Healthcare Trust, Manchester, United Kingdom
Reprints or correspondence: Dr. J. R. Kerr, Dept. of Microbiology, Royal Brompton Hospital, Imperial College London, Sydney St., London SW3 6NP, United Kingdom (firstname.lastname@example.org).
Three cases of chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) that followed acute parvovirus B19 infection were treated with a 5-day course of intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG; 400 mg/kg per day), the only specific treatment for parvovirus B19 infection. We examined the influence of IVIG treatment on the production of cytokines and chemokines in individuals with CFS due to parvovirus B19. IVIG therapy led to clearance of parvovirus B19 viremia, resolution of symptoms, and improvement in physical and functional ability in all patients, as well as resolution of cytokine dysregulation.
Chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) is characterized by severe debilitating fatigue that persists for 6 months and is accompanied by 4 of the following symptoms: impaired memory or concentration, sore throat, tender cervical or axillary lymph nodes, muscle pain, multijoint pain, new headaches, unrefreshing sleep, and postexertional malaise .
Although the causes of and risk factors for CFS are not well defined, epidemiological studies reveal that flulike illnesses suggestive of infective episodes precede the onset in the majority of cases. A major hypothesis for the pathogenesis of CFS is that an infectious trigger, such as the persistence of an infectious agent or other immune stimulus, may lead to a chronic activation of the immune system with abnormal regulation of cytokine production . The resulting dysregulation in cytokine pathways may directly or indirectly contribute to the symptom complex associated with this disorder.
We have previously shown that acute symptomatic parvovirus B19 infection is associated with elevated circulating TNF- and IFN- production  and with particular human leukocyte antigen class 1 and 2 alleles , and it may be followed by the development of CFS [8, 9]. Persistent parvovirus B19 infection is believed to result from a deficiency in the humoral immune response to this virus .
Intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIG) therapy has been shown to be effective for parvovirus B19associated pure RBC aplasia in immunosuppressed persons  and also for several cases of other clinical manifestations in association with persistent parvovirus B19 infection, including 1 case of parvovirus B19-associated CFS .
The purpose of this study was to determine whether IVIG therapy could ameliorate the clinical symptoms and reverse the documented dysregulation in cytokine production in 3 cases of parvovirus B19-associated CFS.
The patients are numbered 2, 8 and 32, as reported elsewhere [8, 9].
Patient 2, as described elsewhere , was a 42-year-old white woman who initially presented with an illness characterized by fever, skin rash, polyarthralgia, and fatigue coincident with an outbreak of parvovirus B19 infection at the school attended by her children.
After a 5-month history of symptoms, she was tested in March 1998 and found to be positive for serum antiparvovirus B19 IgM. This patient also reported a deterioration in memory and concentration, sore throat, painful aching muscles, new headaches, difficulty sleeping, unrefreshing sleep, postexertional malaise, an increased tendency to sweat, dizzy spells, and blurred vision. She had also experienced a sensation of heat in the soles of her feet and hot, dry eyes.
Since the onset of acute parvovirus B19 infection, she had experienced persistent abdominal pain and diarrhea that remained undiagnosed despite extensive investigation, including colonoscopy, and she was being treated with carbamazepine and imipramine. Although she was able to continue working, her illness necessitated frequent time off from work, and eventually she had reduced her work commitment to part time. In addition, her social life had also been markedly curtailed by this illness. She had been treated with physiotherapy that had provided minimal benefit, and so she was referred for rheumatology assessment after a 24-month illness.
The findings of history, examination, and laboratory investigations performed immediately before commencement of IVIG therapy are summarized in table 1. At this time, the patient had had a 26-month history of fatigue, arthralgia, and other symptoms. During the examination, she appeared to be flushed and had no evidence of synovitis. She had pain on external rotation of her left hip, and 7 of 18 tender points were present.
The findings of routine blood investigations, including a complete blood cell count, determination of urea and electrolyte levels, liver function tests, and determination of the erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR), were normal. The patient was found to be positive for serum parvovirus B19 DNA, serum antiparvovirus B19 VP1/2 IgG and antiparvovirus B19 NS1 IgG, and rheumatoid factor (RF), and she was found to be negative for leukocyte parvovirus B19 DNA and antinuclear antibody (ANA). The findings of Schirmer's test were normal. Skeletal radiography findings were normal.
In January 2001, the patient was admitted to hospital for IVIG therapy (Sandoglobulin; Novartis Pharmaceuticals) at a dosage of 400 mg/kg per day for 5 days, after which her symptoms resolved during the next 2 weeks, with a more gradual improvement during the next 2 months. At the time of this writing, her condition remains in remission. The patient subsequently returned to work without sick leave and was able to participate again in family and social activities that were not possible during her illness. Serial serum samples obtained at intervals from the onset of illness were tested for parvovirus B19 markers and cytokines.
Patient 8, as described elsewhere , was a 34-year-old Italian woman who was employed as a schoolteacher and was the mother of 2 young children. She presented in the summer of 1998 with a 3-week history of fever, skin rash, and polyarthralgia. She also complained of pain, a sensation of heat, and swelling in her elbows, shoulders, hands, back, neck, knees, ankles, and feet. Serum samples obtained in June 1998 were found to be positive for antiparvovirus B19 IgM.
After the acute phase, the arthralgia persisted in her elbows, knees, back, neck, fingers, and wrists; it occurred in regular bouts lasting 12 weeks and was associated with feeling feverish and shivery and with recurrence of cold sores. Fatigue was also a prominent feature of the acute phase and persisted throughout the follow-up period until June 2000. Additional symptoms included deterioration in memory and concentration, sore throat, painfully aching muscles, new headaches, difficulty sleeping, unrefreshing sleep, postexertional malaise, increased tendency to sweat, dizzy spells, and blurred vision.
In April 2000, she presented with a 2-month history of palpitations; physical examination revealed bilateral exophthalmos and a diffuse goiter. Serum testing revealed a high level of thyroxine, which confirmed a diagnosis of hyperthyroidism. This illness was brought under control with propranolol and carbimazole therapy, and treatment with carbimazole (60 mg per day) was maintained. The fatigue and related symptoms had necessitated giving up her teaching career, and she was able to socialize only rarely. She was referred for rheumatology assessment after a 24-month illness.
The findings of history, examination, and laboratory investigations performed immediately before commencement of IVIG therapy are summarized in table 1. At this time, the patient had had a 26-month history of fatigue, arthralgia, and other symptoms. During the examination, she was flushed and had no evidence of synovitis, and 7 of 18 tender points were present. The findings of routine blood investigations, including a complete blood cell count, determination of urea and electrolyte levels, liver function tests, and determination of the ESR, were normal.
At follow-up, the patient tested positive for serum parvovirus B19 DNA and serum antiparvovirus B19 VP1/2 IgG but negative for leukocyte parvovirus B19 DNA and antiparvovirus B19 NS1 IgG. She also tested positive for RF and ANA (homogenous ANA titer, 300).
In January 2001, the patient was admitted to the hospital for IVIG therapy (Sandoglobulin) at a dosage of 400 mg/kg per day for 5 days. Within 2 weeks, she felt much improved, and during the next 2 months, she recovered completely. This treatment has enabled her to again participate in family and social activities that were not possible during her illness. Serial serum samples obtained at intervals from the time of onset of illness were tested for parvovirus B19 markers and cytokines.
Patient 32, as described previously , was a 46-year-old white salesman who presented in January 1998 with acute pain and swelling in his hands, knees, and ankles associated with a flulike illness; he tested positive for serum antiparvovirus B19 IgM. Fatigue was present from the beginning of this illness. He had been in very good health before the development of this illness. During the next 2 years, he experienced joint pain in the hips, knees, ankles, wrists, and metacarpal joints.
There was also intermittent swelling in the fingers. Fatigue had increased from the time of acute parvovirus B19 infection until it was necessary for him to sleep for several hours during the day. Although he was able to continue his work as a salesman, his social activities were severely restricted. He also reported a deterioration in memory and concentration, painful aching muscles, new headaches, difficulty sleeping, unrefreshing sleep, postexertional malaise, and an increased tendency to sweat. He was referred for rheumatology assessment after a 24-month illness.
The findings of history, examination, and laboratory investigations performed immediately before commencement of IVIG therapy are summarized in table 1. During examination, the patient was flushed and sleepy, with no evidence of synovitis, and 4 of 18 tender points were present. The findings of routine blood investigations, including a complete blood cell count, determination of urea and electrolyte levels, liver function tests, and determination of the ESR, were normal. Serological investigations revealed that the patient was positive for serum parvovirus B19 DNA but negative for leukocyte parvovirus B19 DNA, serum antiparvovirus B19 VP1/2 IgG, antiparvovirus B19 NS1 IgG, RF, and ANA.
In January 2001, the patient was admitted to the hospital for a 5-day course of IVIG (Sandoglobulin) at a dosage of 400 mg/kg per day. On day 2 of this treatment, he developed a severe headache that lasted 48 h, and, on day 3, his joint pains began to improve. This improvement continued over the ensuing 2 weeks, by which time his fatigue had lessened.
The arthritis was somewhat slower to resolve, but a marked improvement occurred at 3 months after treatment. At this time, his hips, knees, and ankles were virtually free of pain. This improvement continued until he achieved a complete recovery. This treatment has enabled the man to participate again in family and social activities that were not possible during his illness. In particular, he could walk on flat surfaces without a stick. He no longer needed daytime naps after receiving treatment. At the time of this writing, his condition remains in remission. Serial serum samples obtained at intervals of 129 months from the onset of his illness were tested for parvovirus B19 markers and cytokines.
Materials and methods.
Serum samples were tested for antiparvovirus B19 VP2 IgM, by ELISA (Biotrin); antiparvovirus B19 VP1/2 IgG, by Western blot test (Mikrogen); antiparvovirus B19 NS1 IgG, by Western blot (Mikrogen); RF, by latex-particle agglutination (Fujirebio); and ANA, by indirect immunofluorescence. Nested PCR for detection of parvovirus B19 DNA was performed with DNA extracts of serum, as described elsewhere . We have previously shown the sensitivity of this assay to be 110 genome copies .
A panel of cytokines was quantitated in serum specimens. These were measured in duplicate using the Bioplex Protein Array system (Bio-Rad), according to the instructions of the manufacturer. This is a novel, multiplexed, particle-based, flow cytometric assay that uses specific monoclonal antibodies linked to microspheres incorporating distinct proportions of 2 fluorescent dyes.
The assay is able to quantify several mediators in a single sample. Our assay was customized to detect and quantify IL-1, IL-2, IL-4, IL-5, IL-6, IL-8, IL-10, IL-13, TNF-, IFN-, granulocyte-macrophage colony stimulating factor (GM-CSF), and macrophage chemoattractant protein 1 (MCP-1). Mediators were included in this assay according to present knowledge of those upregulated during parvovirus B19 infection and those that may be implicated on the basis of present knowledge of the pathogenesis of parvovirus B19 infection. The limit of detection for these assays is <10 pg/mL on the basis of detectable signal greater than 2 SD above background (Bio-Rad). To standardize this cytokine testing system, we determined cytokine levels in 19 healthy persons.
Mean cytokine levels in 19 healthy persons were as follows: IL-1, 0 pg/mL; IL-2, 0 pg/mL; IL-4, 0 pg/mL; IL-5, 0 pg/mL; IL-6, 2.14 pg/mL (range, 030.91 pg/mL); IL-8, 0 pg/mL; IL-10, 0 pg/mL; IL-13, 0 pg/mL; IFN-, 0 pg/mL; TNF-, 1.62 pg/mL (range, 012.32 pg/mL); GM-CSF, 13.73 pg/mL (range, 067.26); and MCP-1, 0.83 pg/mL (range, 011.14 pg/mL).
In all cases, serum samples contained parvovirus B19 DNA that decreased to less than the limit of detection by our nested PCR assay after IVIG treatment (figures 13). The acute phase of each patient's illness began with a typical acute parvovirus B19 infection coincident with a positive test result for serum antiparvovirus B19 IgM. Patients 2 and 8 mounted IgG responses to parvovirus B19; however, patient 32 did not switch class and tested negative for antiparvovirus B19 IgG antibodies until he was treated with IVIG. In this patient, specific IgG antibodies were detected for the first time after completion of IVIG therapy.
Although many cytokines were quantified, only those that were significantly elevated above normal levels are discussed and included in figures 13. Before initiation of IVIG treatment, all patients had increased levels of MCP-1 and TNF-. After IVIG therapy, MCP-1 and TNF-levels decreased and were consistently less than the limit of detection for the Bioplex protein array system within 36 months of IVIG treatment in patients 2 and 8; however, the decrease was somewhat slower in patient 32.
Patients 2 and 8 had intermittent increases in levels of IFN- and IL-6 during the disease phase, which decreased to baseline levels after the introduction of IVIG treatment. Patient 32 had a slightly different cytokine profile, with an elevated IL-4 concentration before receipt of IVIG therapy, which peaked 6 weeks afterward and then slowly returned to the baseline value. The decrease in the IL-4 concentration after administration of IVIG was similar to that noted for TNF- and MCP-1.
A smaller peak in the IL-2 level also occurred in this patient after administration of IVIG treatment, coincident with the peak in the IL-4 level. An important limitation of the cytokine data was that antigen-specific responses were not assessed, and serum values may not accurately reflect cytokine concentration in the secondary lymphoid compartment. Further studies will be required to address these issues.
IVIG treatment led to a significant improvement in symptoms and functional outcome in 3 patients with parvovirus-associated CFS. We hypothesized that IVIG therapy would be effective in this patient population for the following reasons. IgG antibody prevents in vitro infection of erythroid progenitor cells by parvovirus B19 , and volunteer studies have shown it to be protective .
Individuals with persistent parvovirus infection have a specific defect in humoral immunity to this virus . Because parvovirus is a common infection in the population, with a seroprevalence of 60%70% in blood donors , IVIG is a good means to neutralize antibodies . Finally, IVIG has been shown to be an effective therapy for other clinical syndromes associated with persistent parvovirus infection, such as pure RBC aplasia in immunocompromised individuals  and in sporadic cases of parvovirus B19associated arthritis , vasculitis , fetal anemia , meningoencephalitis , and CFS .
We have previously shown that parvovirus-associated CFS was associated with increased circulating levels of TNF- and IFN- . In this study, all patients had persistent elevations of TNF- and MCP-1 levels that returned to baseline values after IVIG therapy was administered. In one individual, parvovirus-specific IgG was detected for the first time after administration of IVIG treatment. This was associated with an isolated increase in levels of both IL-2 and IL-4 (figure 3), cytokines that are known to be important in immunoglobulin class switching [21, 22].
It has been suggested that detectable circulating IL-2 may protect against chronic symptoms after acute parvovirus infection  and may prevent parvovirus B19 infection of the human fetus . Future studies are required to determine whether persistent parvovirus infection is associated with an antigen-specific defect in IL-2 production and production of other cytokines and whether such abnormalities may be corrected by IVIG therapy.
IVIG has been used to treat idiopathic CFS, and individual trials have shown benefit . However, some trials do not show clinical benefit [27, 28], and a meta-analysis of all of the randomized controlled trials of IVIG therapy for idiopathic CFS was unable to determine whether this treatment had a clear-cut benefit . One possible reason for the conflicting results of individual trials may lie in the heterogeneity of the population of patients with CFS; it is possible that some individuals with idiopathic CFS may have persistent viral illnesses similar to parvovirus that are responsive to IVIG.
However, another possibility is the heterogeneity of IVIG preparations. Notwithstanding, one goal for future studies is to determine what proportion of patients with idiopathic CFS have persistent parvovirus infection and whether screening for this should be routinely performed.
In conclusion, IVIG appears to be a promising treatment for parvovirus-associated CFS. It leads to a significant improvement in symptoms and to functional outcome and clearance of persistent viremia. Our findings provide support for the use of this therapy in parvovirus-associated CFS.
We thank Alex Liversage of Bio-Rad, Hemel Hempstead, United Kingdom, for assistance with cytokine testing, and David Tyrrell, for helpful comments on the article in manuscript.
1. Fukuda K, Straus SE, Hickie I, Sharpe MC, Dobbins JG, Komaroff AL. The chronic fatigue syndrome: a comprehensive approach to its definition and study. The International Chronic Fatigue Syndrome Study Group. Ann Intern Med 1994; 121:9539. First citation in article | PubMed
2. Rasmussen AK, Nielsen H, Andersen V, et al. Chronic fatigue syndromea controlled cross-sectional study. J Rheumatol 1994; 21:152731. First citation in article | PubMed
3. Moss RB, Mercandetti A, Vojdani A. TNF- and chronic fatigue syndrome. J Clin Immunol 1999; 19:3146. First citation in article | PubMed
4. Chao CC, Janoff EN, Hu SX, et al. Altered cytokine release in peripheral blood mononuclear cell cultures from patients with the chronic fatigue syndrome. Cytokine 1991; 3:2928. First citation in article | PubMed
5. MacDonald KL, Osterholm MT, LeDell KH, et al. A case control study to assess possible triggers and cofactors in chronic fatigue syndrome. Am J Med 1996; 100:54854. First citation in article | PubMed
6. Kerr JR, Barah F, Mattey DL, et al. Serum tumour necrosis factor (TNF-) and interferon- (IFN-) are detectable during acute and convalescent parvovirus B19 infection and are associated with prolonged and chronic fatigue. J Gen Virol 2001; 82:30119. First citation in article | PubMed
7. Kerr JR, Mattey DL, Thomson W, Poulton KV, Ollier WER. Association of acute symptomatic parvovirus B19 infection with HLA class I and II alleles. J Infect Dis 2002; 186:44752. First citation in article | Full Text | PubMed
8. Kerr JR, Coyle PV, DeLeys RJ, Patterson CC. Follow-up study of clinical and immunological findings in patients presenting with acute parvovirus B19 infection. J Med Virol 1996; 48:6875. First citation in article | PubMed
9. Kerr JR, Bracewell J, Laing I, et al. Chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) and arthralgia following parvovirus B19 infection. J Rheumatol 2002; 29:595602. First citation in article | PubMed
10. Kurtzman GJ, Cohen BJ, Field AM, Oseas R, Blaese RM, Young NS. Immune response to B19 parvovirus and an antibody defect in persistent viral infection. J Clin Invest 1989; 84:111423. First citation in article | PubMed
11. Kurtzman GJ, Frickhofen NK, Kimball J, Jenkins DW, Niehuis AW, Young NS. Pure red cell aplasia of 10 years duration due to persistent parvovirus infection and its cure with immunoglobulin therapy. N Engl J Med 1989; 321:51923. First citation in article | PubMed
12. Jacobson SK, Daly JS, Thorne GM, McIntosh K. Chronic parvovirus B19 infection resulting in chronic fatigue syndrome: case report and review. Clin Infect Dis 1997; 24:104851. First citation in article | PubMed
13. Barah F, Vallely PJ, Chiswick ML, Cleator GM, Kerr JR. Association of human parvovirus B19 infection with acute meningoencephalitis. Lancet 2001; 358:72930. First citation in article | PubMed
14. Young NS, Mortimer PP, Moore JG, Humphries RK. Characterisation of a virus that causes transient aplastic crisis. J Clin Invest 1984; 73:22430. First citation in article | PubMed
15. Anderson MJ, Higgins PG, Davis LR, et al. Experimental parvoviral infection in humans. J Infect Dis 1985; 152:25765. First citation in article | PubMed
16. Cohen BJ, Buckley M. The prevalence of antibody to human parvovirus B19 in England and Wales. J Med Microbiol 1988; 25:1513. First citation in article | PubMed
17. Anderson LJ. Treatment and prevention of human parvovirus B19 disease. Monogr Virol 1997; 20:13744. First citation in article
18. Stahl HD, Pfeiffer R, Emmrich F. Intravenous treatment with immunoglobulins may improve chronic undifferentiated mono- and oligoarthritis. Clin Exp Rheumatol 2000; 18:5157. First citation in article | PubMed
19. Finkel TH, Torok TJ, Ferguson PJ, et al. Chronic parvovirus B19 infection and systemic necrotising vasculitis: opportunistic infection or aetiological agent? Lancet 1994; 343:12558. First citation in article | PubMed
20. Rugolotto S, Padovani EM, Sanna A, Chiaffoni GP, Marradi PL, Borgna-Pignatti C. Intrauterine anemia due to parvovirus B19: successful treatment with intravenous immunoglobulin. Haematologica 1999; 84:6689. First citation in article | PubMed
21. Fehniger TA, Cooper MA, Caligiuri MA. Interleukin-2 and interleukin-15: immunotherapy for cancer. Cytokine Growth Factor Rev 2002; 13:16983. First citation in article | PubMed
22. Spellberg B, Edwards JE Jr. Type 1/type 2 immunity in infectious diseases. Clin Infect Dis 2001; 32:76102. First citation in article | Full Text | PubMed
23. Jordan JA, Huff D, DeLoia JA. Placental cellular immune response in women infected with human parvovirus B19 during pregnancy. Clin Diagn Lab Immunol 2001; 8:28892. First citation in article | PubMed
24. Rowe KS. Double-blind randomised controlled trial to assess the efficacy of intravenous gamma globulin for the management of chronic fatigue syndrome in adolescents. J Psychiatr Res 1997; 31:13347. First citation in article | PubMed
25. DuBois R. Gamma globulin therapy for chronic monomucleosis syndrome. AIDS Res 1986; 2(Suppl 1):S1915. First citation in article | PubMed
26. Lloyd A, Hickie I, Wakefield D, Boughton C, Dwyer J. A double-blind, placebo-controlled trial of intravenous immunoglobulin therapy in patients with chronic fatigue syndrome. Am J Med 1990; 89:5618. First citation in article | PubMed
27. Peterson PK, Shepard J, Macres M, et al. A controlled trial of intravenous immunoglobulin G in chronic fatigue syndrome. Am J Med 1990; 89:55460. First citation in article | PubMed
28. Vollmer-Conna U, Hickie I, Hadzi-Pavlovic D, et al. Intravenous immunoglobulin is ineffective in the treatment of patients with chronic fatigue syndrome. Am J Med 1997; 103:3843. First citation in article | PubMed
29. Whiting P, Bagnall AM, Sowden AJ, Cornell JE, Mulrow CD, Ramirez G. Interventions for the treatment and management of chronic fatigue syndrome: a systematic review. JAMA 2001; 286:13608. First citation in article | PubMed
. Click on this link for more information including the tables that go with this article.