In a 1993 study published in the New England Journal of Medicine, a team of Harvard researchers reported that Americans actually make more office visits to providers of unconventional health care than they do to conventional primary care physicians. What’s more, we’re apparently willing to pay “out of pocket” for a great deal of such care since it is often not covered by insurance.
It is becoming clear that Americans are seeking to expand their options beyond just conventional medicine. Yet it is also clear that people are not rejecting conventional medicine altogether. Rather, they are opting for a combination of conventional and alternative care—what is now called “integrative” medicine.
Certainly conventional medicine has some important strengths, particularly in emergency care and surgery. However, it has difficulty with chronic illnesses, and its reliance on drugs is problematic: The University of Arizona College of Pharmacy recently reported that 40% of all prescriptions lead to either failure or a new medical problem, and that 119,000 Americans die each year from prescription drugs.
The integrative approach is to seek out the best that all health care traditions have to offer. Although conventional medicine is by far the most common in the U.S. today, there are several others available too, each of which with its own strengths and limitations. Below I will summarize the main traditions available to help people with CFIDS.
In this tradition, CFIDS is considered a complex chronic illness for which there is currently no medical cure. There are drug treatments for specific symptoms, but no one treatment has been found successful for the syndrome as a whole. The greatest hope from the point of view of conventional medicine is for research to find a single cause, such as a virus, for which a drug can then be developed.
From the perspective of Chinese medicine, CFIDS is considered a “chi deficiency” disease. “Chi” is the vital energy or life force that enlivens the human being and energizes our healing processes. Treatment may involve acupuncture and Chinese herbs, for the purposes of building and harmonizing chi. The hope is that with the proper restoration and balance of chi flowing through the body, healing will then take place naturally as the body’s various systems come back into harmony.
This is the health care tradition of India, and has been popularized in the U.S. by Deepak Chopra, M.D. It holds that CFIDS is a result of imbalances in our vital energy caused by inappropriate diet, stress, and buildup of toxins in the body. The main treatments in Ayurveda are a diet that is individually tailored according to your unique energetic nature (your “dosha”), ayurvedic herbs, detoxification, and stress reduction practices such as meditation.
Naturopaths usually view CFIDS as a result of nutritional deficiencies, poor digestion, build-up of toxins in the body, and possibly infection with yeasts and intestinal parasites. They use a combination of herbal medicines, nutritional supplements, dietary therapy, hydrotherapy, exercise, and stress reduction practices. Some naturopaths are also trained in other traditions. Rather than treating disease, their focus is on strengthening the body’s resistance to illness so the body can heal itself.
Homeopathy is not as concerned with the name of the disease as with observing the unique pattern of symptoms in the individual patient. After this close observation, a homeopathic remedy is selected. Two people with CFIDS may receive entirely different remedies. The remedies are extremely dilute quantities of natural substances, in tiny pills. They work by subtly provoking or stimulating the body’s healing responses to a higher level.
Practitioners of mind/body medicine may be physicians, therapists, or any other health care discipline. It has been found to effectively reduce the pain of fibromyalgia, and improve immune functioning—such as increase natural killer cell function which is depressed in CFIDS. It uses meditation, relaxation training, imagery, biofeedback and breath therapy. One of the advantages of mind/body medicine is that is can be used easily at home in the form of daily self-healing practices.
Osteopaths (D.O.’s) are fully licensed physicians like M.D.’s. Their training is the same, except that they receive additional training in therapeutic manipulation of the musculoskeletal system. Many osteopaths practice conventional medicine only. Some, however specialize in manipulative therapies, and research has found osteopathic manipulation helpful with fibromyalgia. Some also use other forms of natural medicine.
Chiropractors primarily treat the health of the body through spinal manipulation. Such manipulation improves the functioning of the nervous system, which is a key to health in all the body’s organs and tissues. Regarding CFIDS, the hope is that by improving the flow of energy through the nervous system, the body’s healing mechanisms, including the immune system, will restore harmony and work more effectively.
Massage Therapy and Bodywork These therapies are effective in relieving stress that is held in the body, improving blood and lymph circulation, and creating an overall feeling of well-being. They can also help to remove blockages to the flow of vital energy through the body in the form or muscular tension and holding patterns. Research is under way at the University of Miami on the effect of massage therapy for CFIDS.
Conclusion: Choosing Your Medicine
Given all these options, how do you choose what’s right for you? Every healthcare
tradition has its advocates who argue that theirs is the best approach, superior to the others However, with CFIDS, the reality is that people have been helped by all of the above traditions. With each and every approach, there are former PWC’s who will tell you they owe their recovery to it.
In my experience, the best advice is to be open to trying a variety of approaches. If one tradition doesn’t seem to help, don’t give up: and consider yourself untreatable. Different traditions work for different people, and integration of multiple traditions may be best of all. Fortunately, in America today we are blessed with an abundance of health care options.
Editor’s Note: Dr. Collinge began working CFIDS during the Lake Tahoe epidemic. He currently has a new book entitled The American Holistic Health Association Complete Guide to Alternative Medicine. His book Recovering from Chronic Fatigue Syndrome: A Guide to Self Empowerment and corresponding, the Home Self-Empowerment Program, are available from the Health Buyers Club.