The Flu Shot Dilemma – And Things to Know

To get a flu shot or not to get a flu shot – that’s the question FM and ME/CFS patients face each fall. If we take the shot, we risk triggering an FM flare or an ME/CFS relapse. But if we don’t take the shot and get the flu, the effects can be severe and long-lasting. What’s a patient to do?

Weighing the Risks

Charles Lapp, MD – director of the Hunter-Hopkins Center for ME/CFS/FM in Charlotte, NC – says that as a general rule he does not recommend flu shots for his patients. With two notable exceptions:

1. Patients who have taken flu vaccinations in the past and tolerated them well.

2. Patients who have a serious chronic illness (such as emphysema, diabetes or heart disease) in addition to FM or ME/CFS.

According to Dr. Lapp, in addition to the fact that some ME/CFS/FM patients relapse after receiving flu shots, many do not develop antibodies to the vaccination. So not only might you experience a relapse, but you might not even develop immunity to the influenza virus.

When weighing the risks, you also have to take into account how likely you are to be exposed to the flu. If you work in the medical field or in a school, or do much traveling, you’re at much greater risk of catching the flu than if you are at home most of the time and have limited contact with the public. When all is said and done, you and your doctor will have to decide whether the risks outweigh the benefits, or vice versa.

Taking Precautions

Whether or not you decide to get a flu shot, it’s especially important this time of year to take extra precautions to prevent not only the flu, but also colds and other bugs. The recommendations for preventing the flu are the same as for preventing a cold:

1. Wash your hands frequently. The first thing you should do when you arrive home is wash your hands with soap and water, particularly if you have been out in public. This should become your ritual, and I think it is the single most important thing patients can do to improve their health. Ask family members and guests to do the same, and they will respect you for it. Your house is your sanctuary, and you need to keep it virus free.

2. Cold and flu viruses enter your body through your eyes, nose and mouth, so never touch your hands to your face – unless they’re sparkling clean.

3. Flu viruses make their way into your house by way of items that you have touched while you were out in public, including your cell phone and keys. Prevent this from happening by wiping these items down with a sanitizing hand wipe, such as those made by CloroxR and LysolR. It takes only 30 seconds, and this ounce of prevention is worth many pounds of cure.

4. Central heating dries you out and makes you more susceptible to cold and flu viruses, so it’s important to drink lots of water and get plenty of fresh air to keep your body hydrated.

What If I Get the Flu Anyway?

Should you get the flu, there are antiviral medications available to help shorten the time and reduce the severity of it, but they need to be taken within 72 hours of onset. Antivirals include:

  • SymmetrelR (amantidine) – 100 mg twice a day for 5 days, for influenza A

  • FlumadeneR (ramantidine) – 100 mg twice a day for 5 days, for influenza A

  • RelenzaR (zanamivir, an inhaler) – 2 puffs twice a day for 5 days, for influenza A or B

  • TamifluR (oseltamivir phosphate) – One tab twice a day for 5 days, for influenza A or B

  • Dr. Lapp prefers Tamiflu and Relenza because some flu strains have developed a resistance to the other antivirals.

    In addition to the antivirals, there are also homeopathic remedies available, such as OscillococcinumR (o-sill-o-cox-see-num), which has been shown in clinical studies to reduce the duration of flu symptoms. Oscillococcinum can be purchased at most drug stores and health food stores.

    Wishing you a flu-free season,

    Rich Carson

    ProHealth Founder and patient advocate


    Note: This information has not been evaluated by the FDA. It is generic and not meant to prevent, diagnose, treat, or cure any illness, condition, or disease. It is very important that you make no change in your healthcare plan or health support regimen without researching and discussing it in collaboration with your professional healthcare team.

    1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (207 votes, average: 3.30 out of 5)

    4 thoughts on “The Flu Shot Dilemma – And Things to Know”

    1. AndyTheJaw says:

      Whilst Amantadine and Rimantadine are effective against strains of Influenza A, Ribavirin is effective against many strains of Influenza A and Influenza B. Combine Symmetrel, alias Symmetrel with Ribavirin, and you have an amplified antiviral effect, and as demonstrated in my case, a significantly faster removal of the infection and recovery.

      Even better, also throw in Inosine Pranobex as an antiviral drug that works through boosting the immune response, and the result is even better.

      If Inosine Pranobex is not available, noting that the name used in Canada is Isoprinosine, and Imunovir in the UK, try Inosine and PABA together for a similar, safe immune boost. The only caution is that Inosine, and therefore Inosine Pranobex, increases the levels of Uric Acid during treatment. For those who are sensitive to Gout, also take Cherry Juice that neutralises the effects of excess uric acid.

    2. merida says:

      I had the flu vaccine for a number of yrs after I developed ME in 1970 without problems, it wasn’t until 15yrs later I began to get serious affects from the vaccine over 3yrs finally developing pleurisy. However the flu itself left me with pneumonia in 2004+a flare up of the ME, I’ve been taking the homoepathic nosode for flu each yr since which gives some protection. I’m pleased to know that there may be something else I can use since my asthma consultant says that I must not have the vaccine, or any others. I’d like to know if there is anything similar I can take for the common cold- currently making me feel very lethargic? Merida.

    3. merida says:

      I have chronic, severe, brittle asthma & am frequently on steroids (prednisolone) as well as my normal asthma meds-Salbutamol nebules2.5mg, seratide 250mg & montelukast, my PEF is between 170-240 about 50% of what it normally was. Since June I’ve had 3 courses of prednisolone 30 & 40mgs/day & I’m now going on 5mg/day long term. I’m wondering if anybody else has had long term steroids & what effects this had on the ME?
      I have no real alternative & I’ve had asthma 60yrs after developing whooping cough at a yr old. I just want to be prepared. Thanks, Merida.

    4. AndyTheJaw says:

      The best methods that I have found to deal with a common cold include the use of Zinc Gluconate Lozenges, and the nasal spray called First Defence in the UK. They both work in a similar manner.

      Zinc Gluconate lozenges are sucked in the mouth and release Zinc Ions that coat the back of the throat. Once located in that area, they block viral penetration into cells in that area thereby blocking the progress of the cold virus. However, for this to work, it is necessary to wait about half an hour after eating and or drinking before using the lozenges, and wait at least an hour after taking a lozenge before eating or drinking. The reason is simple, you need to keep the throat coated with the Zinc Ions for this to stop the common cold.

      First defence is a nasal spray that also delivers zinc ions, but to the back of the nasal passage, the place where infection usually starts.

      Finnaly, Inosine Pranobex, through boosting the immune system, also helps to defeat a common cold.



    Leave a Reply